// Business Hiring

A Tale of Two Sides

6 min read · Business
Summary 6 min read

Hiring freelance copywriters surfaced a striking pattern: among candidates with similar experience and portfolios, the men quoted $50–$100 an hour while the women, including the most experienced, quoted $25–$50. An anecdotal but telling look at how the wage gap can appear even when freelancers set their own rates.

Last week I put a post on a local Facebook group for freelancers looking for copywriters to work with for projects B&G is involved with. The response was overwhelming, had more people respond than I could handle and talk to. I also posted the request on Twitter, the response there was completely different. Only 3 people reached out on Twitter and they were all from the UK, not a place I typically have any reach in.

Those who responded via Twitter made me think that the way people in the UK are looking for work is fundamentally different than people in other locations. They are making a proactive effort to look for keywords and reach out that way, and that was a cool thing to note. But that’s not the most interesting part of that process.

One noteworthy stat is that out of the approximately 10 people I talked to, 8 were female and 2 were male. I don’t know what the overall stats are in the general copywriting population, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s similar or completely different. I was definitely happy to see many females feel empowered enough to work as freelancers and be independent because many in the past have voiced their trepidation about taking that step and everything that goes with it.

There was another stat that caught me off guard and I tried to figure out some predictors for the difference in that specific category, but to avoid getting lost in who I am referencing since I cannot name names, it would be easier to talk about groups instead. The groups that made sense to me are as follows:

Group A:
Rate: $50/hr — $100/hr
Experience: splits into 2:
 a. Previous work in the tech domain but recently went into the freelance market
 b. Writing experience, freelance on the side when time permits
Location: Austin and overseas
Portfolio: Non major brands
Contact point: Personal referral and local FB group

Group B:
Rate: $50/hr
Experience: between 8 to 10 years of experience doing freelance copywriting 
Location: Austin and overseas
Portfolio: Major brands with name recognition
Contact point: Twitter and local FB group

Group C:
Rate: ~$25/hr
Experience: 0–2 years of experience doing freelance copywriting
Location: Austin and overseas
Portfolio: Non major brands
Contact point: Twitter and local FB group

The difference in pricing between Group B and C is obvious, at least to me. The level of experience and portfolio of Group B justifies the rate compared to Group C. But what explains The difference between Group B and A? For that matter, what’s the difference between Group A and C? If you look at it objectively, The only difference between Groups A and C is the rate. So what explains that?

We can try to make a bunch of assumptions, for example, we can assume that Group A is better at marketing their own skills and is a highly thought after group. I would call BS on that because of the Twitter thing. I talked about it already, and to me, those who reached out through Twitter have put in more work and thought into it and have figured out how to reach across continents and get to potential clients. Group A does not contain anyone from the Twitter group. So that assumption is immediately shut down, at least in my opinion.

The only difference I can think of is the following: sex/gender. Group A is all males, Group B & C are all females. That’s a criterion I left out because I am trying to look at it from a very objective perspective. But when you add it to the mix, it stands out. I am, by no means, saying it’s the only reason for the difference. Better knowledge of the market, better training, family related reasons, etc all can be the reason for the difference. I don’t know for sure. But I also can’t help but think of the men to women wage gap in the world and it seems to me that this is yet another example of the same thing.

What’s striking the most to me is that in this example, it’s self-inflicted. Somehow. This is pure speculation obviously, but what I’m trying to say is that this is not a company or a boss paying women less. This is women valuing their services less. With the full knowledge of the caveat that it might be market driven and all sorts of outside forces are interfering. But what I know for sure is that I started interviewing people with the mindset that I will rely on the freelancers themselves to set the tone, especially with regards to their rates and what they want to charge. I said it to many of them while talking to them that I was not going to force anything, including pricing, on them and wanted them to lead in that area. I made it clear that I was not operating based on a specific budget, but instead, that I am flexible and willing to work within their comfort zone. What I hoped would happen is that it will not box them in and give them the opportunity to make their best pitch. I was preparing myself for people to make bids as high as $100/hr (I wouldn’t be able to afford that, but I was ready for it).

This is anecdotal evidence, I realize that. It is still important to me to share these experiences, and I hope it benefits at the very least 1 person in the future.

PS: It is easy to conclude that I am asking the men to lower their price, which means I am messing with another person’s income and livelihood. That is by no means what I am asking for. If the market is at the $25/hr range and the men are asking for 2x or 4x that, then it would be prudent for them to adjust. If the market can handle the $50/hr — $100/hr range then the women in Group B and C should adjust to that range accordingly.

PPS: I know that I am exposing my cards on the table so to speak by letting people know that I am willing to pay them more than what they’ve asked for. Abso-fucking-lutely. I am always for paying someone their fair share instead of trying to squeeze every penny, I have done it before where an employee asked for X amount for a yearly salary and I offered them 1.75X (amounts left vague because it’s a sensitive issue, but think what an average salary might be, set that as X and you get an idea of the big difference between that and 1.75X that is). It is how I want my own clients to treat me, and it will always be how I treat others.

Bear & Giraffe Advisory

We partner with founders and tech leads to build sustainable Rails architecture, untangle monoliths, and scale pragmatic systems.

Schedule a Strategy Call
ESC

Type to search 38 posts